KitchenAid Cold Brew Coffee Maker KCM5912 review best for smooth iced coffee lovers

Description

Smooth Design and Build Quality

The KitchenAid 38 oz Cold Brew Coffee Maker – KCM5912SX immediately stands out with its brushed stainless steel and glass construction, which doesn’t just look premium but also feels durable in everyday use. Its compact size, with dimensions of 8″ x 7.2″ x 8.48″, fits seamlessly into my fridge without taking up much space. I found the built-in stainless steel tap incredibly convenient—it’s such a sleek addition that makes dispensing cold brew effortless and mess-free. Plus, the carrying handle is a thoughtful touch, especially when transporting it from the fridge to the counter.

While the design is undeniably attractive, I did notice that the glass carafe can feel slightly fragile, particularly when washing it. If you’re as clumsy as I am before that first sip of caffeine, you might want to handle it carefully.

Simple Brewing Process

What blew me away about this cold brew coffee maker is how straightforward the brewing process is. You just add coffee grounds to the stainless steel reusable steeper (which, by the way, is labeled with fill-level indicators—super handy), fill the carafe with filtered water, and then let it steep in the fridge. The result? A smooth, rich, and full-bodied flavor that rivals coffee shop quality.

One small quirk, though, is the 12-hour steeping time. While it’s not a dealbreaker, it does require some planning ahead. For those impulsive coffee cravings, waiting overnight might test your patience. Still, the flavor payoff is worth it.

Positives

The product genuinely impressed me with its features and usability. Here are some key benefits I noticed:

• Reusable stainless steel steeper eliminates the need for disposable filters, making it eco-friendly and cost-effective.
• The coffee concentrate stays fresh in the fridge for up to two weeks, which is ideal for busy mornings.
• Its small footprint fits perfectly in both my refrigerator and on the kitchen counter.
• The streamlined design is not only aesthetic but also makes cleaning a breeze.

Drawbacks

Like any product, this cold brew coffee maker isn’t without its areas for improvement:

• The glass material, while beautiful, feels a tad delicate and prone to breakage.
• Steeping for 12 hours can be a long wait for those who need their caffeine fix immediately.
• The tap mechanism, though convenient, requires regular cleaning to avoid clogs, especially if fine coffee grounds sneak through the steeper.

Performance and Taste

The flavor of the cold brew this machine produces is nothing short of spectacular. I’ve tried it with different coffee brands and grind sizes, and every batch turned out smooth and balanced, without any bitterness. Whether you mix the concentrate with water, milk, or even use it as a base for smoothies, the versatility is fantastic.

That said, the ratio of 2 oz of concentrate to 6 oz of liquid is something you’ll want to play around with. I preferred a slightly stronger mix, while my partner liked it a bit lighter. The flexibility to adjust the strength is a definite plus.

Competitive Options

Compared to other cold brew coffee makers I’ve used, like the Takeya Deluxe Cold Brew Coffee Maker, the KitchenAid version feels much more premium due to its stainless steel and glass build. The Takeya, while more affordable, relies on plastic components and lacks the same sleek aesthetic. On the other hand, the OXO Good Grips Cold Brew Coffee Maker offers a similar quality of brew but requires more counter space and has a less intuitive design.

Where the KitchenAid excels is in its compact size and portability, making it perfect for both small apartments and larger households. However, if you’re looking for a budget-friendly option, there are cheaper alternatives that still deliver decent results.

Cost-Effectiveness

While this coffee maker sits at a slightly higher price point than some of its competitors, I’d argue it offers excellent value for money. The materials ensure longevity, and the ability to store fresh coffee for two weeks means fewer trips to the café, ultimately saving money in the long run. Its reusable steeper further reduces waste, which is a bonus for environmentally conscious buyers.

If high-quality cold brew is a daily must-have for you, this product feels like a worthy investment.

Additional information